top button
Flag Notify
    Connect to us
      Site Registration

Site Registration

Moving from svn to GIT

+1 vote

I am trying to move from svn to GIT. With svn I use ssh and a svnserve wrapper like this one :

#!/bin/shumask 002exec /usr/bin/svnserve "$@" -r /very/long/path/to/projets

So I can use URI like this one : svn co svn+ssh://
How can I achieve the same behavior with git (i.e. something like git clone ?

posted Sep 27, 2013 by Naveena Garg

Share this question
Facebook Share Button Twitter Share Button LinkedIn Share Button

1 Answer

+1 vote
Best answer

Nothing different if you're okay with having real system Unix accounts for your developer on a target system. The only problem is short pathnames of projects but I'll show ways to deal with it after explaining the basic setup.

The main premise to make things work is that your Git-repositories should be group-shared. Git has support for this, but for convenience you'd better off helping it to do its part of the work properly.

1) Install Git. There's no special "server-side Git" binary if you intend to access your repositories using SSH [*], so just install Git like apt-get install git.

2) Make sure all your system accounts for Git developers are members of a single special group -- be it "devel" or "git", -- it doesn't matter. Suppose we've picked "git" for this.

3) Create a central place for your repositories. On a typical GNU/Linux system conforming to FHS, I'd recommend to create the "/srv/git" directory (you already have "/srv") and make it belong to root:git and have access rights 2755 (or 2750 if you're paranoid), that is, group writable with group sticky bit set on.

4) For each of your project, create a *bare, shared* repository by running something like this:

 # cd /srv/git
 # umask 002
 # git init --bare --shared project1.git

Verify that the created project directory and its files have sensible access rights -- the "--shared" option which is short for "--shared=group" ensures the directory is group-writable and has group sticky bit set on it, and the step (3) should have made the directory's owning group to be "git".

5) Now try to push something to is from a client:

 git remote add origin ssh://
 git push origin master

You can now see that you can't easily drop the leading part of the project's directory pathname from the remote repository's URL because there's no layer of indirection when accessing Git repositories via SSH: the client Git process just spawns another Git process on the remote machine after setting up an SSH channel, and hands it off the pathname. The only supported shortcut is ~ with the expected meaning.

I'd say that is not really a problem because:

1) Most of the time you're working with named remotes, so you only have to type in the URL once.
2) If the repositories are located in a somewhat standardized place (/srv/git), the leading pathname part is not a big deal to type.

Anyway, there's another approach which is a layer of indirection between you and Git. These days, a low-level de-facto standard tool for this is gitolite []. It provides *virtualized* Git users (so that you only have one system account to access Git repositories, and still each developer has their own SSH key), repository- and branch-level access controls, and more. And as a by-product, since it requires all the repositories be located under a single directory, and it knows which one, it provides for short-cut syntax, like


[*] There's a special Git daemon, unsurprisingly called git-daemon, which is able to serve Git repositories: unauthenticated and hence read-only (but you can turn certain knobs to make it serve R/W as well--in certain controlled environments this might be OK to do). This daemon works kind of like svnserve in that it allows to specify a base directory for the projects using its "--base-path" command-line option.

answer Sep 27, 2013 by Abhay Kulkarni
Similar Questions
+1 vote

I would like to use Git with a SVN, so I try to clone the SVN repo with "git svn clone svn://myserver", it is a repo without trunk etc. Git reports the error "Couldn't find a repository". The SVN repo uses an authentification (username & password) and a normalsvn checkout works well.
How can I use the SVN repo with Git?

+3 votes

We are tasked to move a code branch named "A" within SVN repo to Git. We also have trunk merges going on between "A" and trunk in SVN.Is it possible to set up with Git and SVN such that1) Trunk changes in SVN could be propagated to Git version control ?If not, how can we resolve this need with an efficient setup?

We don't think it is possible but we like to confirm.

+2 votes

I am trying to git-svn clone
and I cannot say I am much successful. Every couple of hundred of commits I get this:

RA layer request failed: REPORT of '/repository/calendarserver/!svn/vcc/default': could not connect to
server ( at /usr/local/share/perl5/Git/SVN/ line 290.

and git-svn stops. When restarting git svn fetch, it fetches another couple of hundred commits and then fails again. Given that there are 11000+ commits just in the trunk, I am afraid of a long long night. Did anybody managed to clone this repo? Or is there some way how to make git-svn more patient (this error
means the SVN server is a bit flakey, right)?